Erin Foster defends 'Nobody Wants This' amid Adam Brody Gaza row

Erin Foster has publicly responded to Adam Brody’s controversial remarks about Israel and Palestine, stating she disagrees with his characterization of the war in Gaza as a genocide, while affirming that differing views are valid ^[1]. The Nobody Wants This creator, whose Netflix romcom draws on her own conversion to Judaism, described her show as a 'love letter to Judaism' and a response to the lack of positive Jewish representation in media.

Brody, who portrays Rabbi Noah Roklov in the series, made his comments in a September interview with GQ, where he stated he believes Israel’s actions in Gaza constitute a genocide and expressed support for a free Palestine ^[1]. He also acknowledged he has not spoken publicly about the conflict before, explaining he only responds to direct questions and does not wear political symbols, though he said he should perhaps do more.

Foster, however, has previously stated it would not be appropriate to address the Israel-Palestine conflict in the show, noting she has her own views but believes it’s not right to speak for large communities ^[1]. She reiterated that her intention was to portray Judaism with warmth and authenticity, not to engage in political debate.

Rabbi Steve Leder, a technical consultant for the first season, condemned Brody’s comments as 'shocking' and 'disgusting', warning that using the term 'genocide' casually undermines its gravity ^[1]. He urged those unfamiliar with the topic to refrain from public commentary.

The series, which stars Kristen Bell as an agnostic sex podcaster who falls for a rabbi, has been praised for its nuanced portrayal of Jewish identity and interfaith relationships ^[1]. Season three is now streaming on Netflix.

Foster emphasized that while she loves Brody, she respects that people hold different views — a stance she likened to dinner table debates around the world ^[1]. The story was first reported by The Independent.